Sixteen Acres: Architecture and the Outrageous Struggle for the Future of Ground Zero

Book Description

When we stand in downtown Manhattan in the future and look up and ask, 'Why?'-Why is it so strange, so rude, so striving, so right, so wrong?-we will have Sixteen Acres to give us the answers. Tracing the redevelopment of the World Trade Center site from graveyard to playground for high design, insurgent critic Philip Nobel strips away the hyperbole to reveal the secret life of the century's most charged building project. Providing a tally of deceptions and betrayals, a look at the meaning of events beyond the pieties of the moment, and a running bestiary of the main players-developers and bureaucrats, star architects and amateur fantasists, politicians and the well-spun press-Nobel's book bares the crucial moments as factions and institutions converge to create a noisy new culture at Ground Zero. Tragic and comic by turns, full of low dealings and high dud-geon, Sixteen Acres takes us behind the scenes at a site in search of its sanctity, exposing the reconstruction as the flawed product of a complicated city: driven by money, hamstrung by politics, burdened by the wounds it is somehow supposed to heal.

Customer Reviews:

"Architecture is the art of compromise''.......2006-02-05

`'Sixteen Acres. Architecture and the outrageous struggle for the future of Ground Zero'' by Philip Nobel.

`'Architecture is the art of compromise.''
Daniel Liebeskind
One of the top architecture critics , Philip Nobel takes the readers of his book on an amazing trip, deep into the world of `' the outrageous struggle'' among architects, politicians, developers and businessmen responsible for the rebuilding of Ground Zero in order to fill in the void that has been created at those sixteen acres. It has been an enriching and at the same time interesting experience to read it. This non- fictional account of what has been happening behind the scenes at Lower Manhattan among some crucial players in this game like Larry
Silverstein, Port Authority, the LMDC, Governor George Pataki and other politicians or members of families who lost their loved ones in the tragedy, in fact reads like an extraordinary novel. With his in- depth analysis and an incredibly realistic style of writing, his work can be easily understood not only by professionals but those who know nothing about architecture as well. The book artfully blends some historical information about architecture together with real dramatic life events and very often shocking, hair-rising gossip. As Liebeskind puts it, you need compromise in order to design and create new buildings, ones that will `' speak the unspeakable'' and fairly fill in the void, and at the same time satisfy everyone's needs and wishes. Can this actually be achieved in real life? With so many players involved it might turn out to be a pretty difficult task. Who is the winner and who looses? The book written by Nobel is a great eye-opener shedding new lights on this controversial issue of rebuilding Ground Zero.
To put the message across the author decided to divide the book into twelve chapters devoting extra space for prologue and epilogue. Starting with the description on Ground Zero, touches upon some architectural streams in the past. The plot is expanded with every chapter, rising climax in middle chapters speaking of the competition and actual struggle.
At first it seems almost incredible how by chance the star architects like Gehry or Koolhaans just happen to be in New York when the attack happens. Many designers make numerous trips to the site in order to understand, contemplate, explain, search for reasons and answers. Was the void indeed fixable? Or maybe it should remain intact. Questions were piling up. As Giedion puts it buildings are `' human landmarks which men have created as symbols for their ideals , their aims, and for their actions''. The commercial buildings of WTC represented so many ideals, standing symbolic and triumphant in the skyline of the city. `'Buildings bear silent witness to what we do'' Nobel suggests, they are our immortality on the earth and they are our landmarks. Now that they are torn down mankind looses witness to humanity. How can one rebuild those lost landmarks? The meaning is lost, now it was left to architects to find it back.
The competition for the new design was certainly a controversial and time consuming task. The author presents us with an in- depth report of what actually happened, all the intrigues and insurmountable questions being asked by a wide cast of characters involved. Money driven developers together with architects loose themselves in searching for meaning. With every single page flipped over the plot shifts its pace, competition gets more and more dramatic, most of all due to that convoluted bureaucratic processes. Finally at its peak Daniel Liebeskind appears with the answer, and his `' Memory Foundations'' win the contest. This Jewish immigrant from Poland happens to know the answer, which is freedom, democracy and independence. His soaring Freedom Tower is going to reach up till 1,777 feet high in order to make a connection with Declaration of Independence. At the end of his presentation he says: `'Life victorious!''. Soon after that he is chosen to be the master planner for the reconstruction of the site. Time will show that this will not be the end, but an offset for another struggle, this time with the powerful Port Authority and LMDC. Before the developers intrude and start influencing Libeskind` s vision, eventually forcing him to cooperate with David Childs, the milk is spilled and gossip enters the media. The media takes its part in it `' tarring the Liebeskinds as alien- worshipping cloners'' Just how far one can go with the intrigues of the century` s most decisive and charged building project. For some players it seemed that George Pataki was the final decision maker in the game. Many questions still remain unanswered. The author tells the story proper with minute details and indeed is meticulous in recording it. At times it almost reads like a soap opera.
In my opinion, what the book lacks is the images or pictures of the designs mentioned. That would help a lot to envision what was being said at times.
The final chapter of the book deals with another contest, this time for the memorial design, which eventually is won by Arad and his `' Reflecting Absence''. Libeskind` s vision is changed from the original one, money wins again, in the end, like all politics, the final decisions for the site were created by a compromise. Again I will quote the master planner: `'Architecture is the art of compromise''. To reach that is definitely difficult, `'to build Art with a capital A'' (Steve Cuozzo) is as well difficult those days, especially when politics and business gets involved in the process.

by Joanna Pszczola, Poland

A lip lock with reality.......2005-08-28

Sixteen Acres is a gripping read for any architect or citizen who hopes that a monumental building in this era can be transcendent. No where have I seen such a thorough accounting of the forces that come to bear on the form of a building. Sixteen Acres is the record of how the desire of the American people to find an expression for the loss they suffered-or the telling off they wished to do-was shaped by the many powerful forces that acted on the site: Governor Pataki's aspirations, the widows', the mayor's, the LMDC, the Port Authority, Larry Silverman's 99 year lease. The book is truly about the profession of "architecture and the outrageous struggle for the future of Ground Zero."

As Mr. Nobel says "...architecture remains the most prominent and most culturally engaged of all the arts. It is also the most contingent-an art that is neither high nor low, an art that gets to art only after locking lips with reality: satisfying a client, securing funds and permits and insurance, getting built." This book paints the lip lock in glowing detail. He has the wisdom to recognize that at the end of the day "...when the politicians line up to cut their ribbons, whatever [building] shades the dais that day will be at once stranger and more fitting than anything they had imagined when they set about to govern its birth. In a way it will be perfect."

For young architects and those who think design is about the power of their vision, this eye-opener will help them see that in addition to having their vision, they must also design the process; that is, they must so understand the interests of the various parties that they can target the area of the overlap. In that area, on any particular job, will be the perfect solution.

Inexplicable lack of illustrations a major flaw in this book.......2005-03-10

Several months ago I read the James Glanz and Eric Lipton book "City In The Sky: The Rise and Fall of The World Trade Center". That book, authored by a pair of New York Times reporters, chronicled the long history of the project from the germ of an idea at the 1939 World's Fair, to the design and planning of a project unlike any other in the history of mankind, to the cataclysmic events of September 11th, 2001. Since I enjoyed that book so much I was very excited when I came across "Sixteen Acres". It seemed to me the perfect sequel to "City In The Sky". Author Philip Nobel writes about architecture for the New York Times and set about the business of documenting the incredibly complicated and sometimes acrimonious process of redeveloping the World Trade Center site.
As one might well imagine, the job of designing a replacement for the WTC was an almost impossible task. There were pressures from so many stakeholders including the families of the victims, the politicians, the various bureaucracies, the tenants as well as from Larry Silverstein, who just six weeks before the attack, had signed a 99 year lease to operate the WTC. Then there was the epic struggle between the competing architects and their visions of what the real estate should look like when all was said and done.
I found that Nobel did a pretty fair job in describing the process and introducing the reader to the various players involved in this drama. But I also found that the author frequently seemed to forget that many readers have absolutely no training in design and architecture. While I thought I was getting the gist of what he was trying to convey, I often felt I was missing something in the translation. And that is why illustrations would have been so helpful. Had I been able to turn to refer to drawings of the proposals Nobel was discussing, I feel I could have gotten a great deal more from this book. It is really too bad and for this reason "Sixteen Acres" is not a book that I can enthusiastically recommend.

Book Description

The beautiful and seductive images of an overlooked movement, reproduced in their full tonal range.

Much has been written about Alfred Stieglitz and his role in establishing photography as an art. Little attention, however, has been paid to the pictorial photographers who followed Stieglitz, among them Imo Jean Cunningham, Edward Weston, Clarence H. White, and a host of others who, in a widespread movement, approached photography in a painterly fashion, creating beautiful images through the use of careful lighting, manipulated tones, soft focus effects, and artistic compositions.

In this important volume, Christian A. Peterson finally gives the pictorialists of the first half of the twentieth century their due. He describes the backgrounds of the movement, their methods, the photo clubs they belonged to, and their work, illustrated here with ninety-three stunning productions. The movement seemed to die out, Peterson suggests, with the rising popularity of 35mm photography in mid-century, when the care and slow working procedures required by large-format cameras became unpopular.

Christian A. Peterson is associate curator of photography at the Minneapolis Institute of Arts and author of Alfred Stieglitz's Camera Notes, also from Norton. 93 full-color photographs.

Average customer rating:
After the Photo-Secession: American Pictorial Photography, 1910-1955
Christian A. Peterson
Manufacturer: W.W. Norton
ProductGroup: Book
Binding: Paperback
ASIN: B000K13PGA

Book Description

George Shepherd provides a popular democratic theory and strategy for democratic transition in the world. He demonstrates how popular democratic ideas have created universal human rights uprisings and popular movements, and he shows how real opposition is building to elite rule. Building on the old liberal and new associative rights of the democratic tradition of the Western world from Harold Laski and Jacques Maritain in Europe to the moral realism of Martin Luther King Jr., John Rawls, and David Brower in America, Professor Shepherd proposes numerous reforms in the economic and political systems that can occur through popular politics and participatory economics. Of considerable interest to activists, concerned citizens, and scholars involved in the debates over democracy and current economic-political policies.

Popular Politics: Renewing Democracy for a Sustainable World

Average customer rating:

Popular Politics: Renewing Democracy for a Sustainable World
George W. Shepherd
Manufacturer: Praeger Publishers
ProductGroup: Book
Binding: Paperback
ASIN: B000ORPU0E

Book Description

Our business environment is one of record pace and quick productivity. Technology has enabled us to communicate and produce in a way we never thought possible. However, as we move through our careers, it's still important to slow down and remember that it always pays to have good manners. Business Etiquette and Protocol is designed for today's high-speed professionals who value the human element in achieving business success. Business Etiquette and Protocol is one title in the Professional Development Series by South-Western. This series is the perfect resource for learning the non-technical strategies and tactics needed to compete in today's business world.

Customer Reviews:

Book for those starting a business career.......2007-06-06

I purchased the book as a requirement for an elective business class that I was taking as a part of a technical master's degree I was pursuing. I have found the book useful in my business career and have referenced it once in a while. The book has been borrowed by friends as they train new employees in dining etiquette and sales calls. Although I do not agree with all of the ideas presented, I have found the book useful in defining how one should act in business situations.

Company Manners: An Insider Tells How to Succeed in the Real World of Corporate Protocol and Power Politics

Average customer rating:

Company Manners: An Insider Tells How to Succeed in the Real World of Corporate Protocol and Power Politics
Lois Wyse
Manufacturer: McGraw-Hill
ProductGroup: Book
Binding: Paperback

General | Business & Investing | Subjects | Books
ASIN: 0070721963

Average customer rating:

Office Etiquette & Protocol
Learning Express
Manufacturer: Learning Express (NY)
ProductGroup: Book
Binding: Paperback

General | Business & Investing | Subjects | Books

Etiquette | Business Life | Business & Investing | Subjects | Books

General | Etiquette | Reference | Subjects | Books

General | Reference | Subjects | Books
Similar Items:

Business Etiquette for Dummies

ASIN: 1576851451

Book Description

How do you succeed in business? Everyone knows the first requirement: Be good at your job. But there is a second skill that can be every bit as important and that no on-the-job training covers: fitting in. The rules are subtle and unwritten, from wearing the right clothes to dealing with bosses, co-workers, and clientsùgood and bad. A major mistake can sink you. Get it right, from the start, by following the simple 20-step program in Office Etiquette & Protocol.

Customer Reviews:

A small book witha big impact.......2001-06-13

My friend gave me this book and I thought it was great. I liked what he said about that governments and churches cannot create wealth only distribute it and that God loves businesses that glorify him. This is a small book but full of great insights that I have not found in many popular business books today. What a great little find. I highly recommend it!

Book Description

Despite the fact that it was events on the North-West Frontier which perennially awed and captivated Victorian audiences, British India's North-East Frontier saw at least as much military activity. Even the heroid 11-day defence of the isolated outpost of Kohima against overwhelming odds – fewer than 200 British-officered troops against perhaps 6,000 Nagas – failed to capture the public imagination. Today, after the passage of another century, Britain's numerous campaigns and conquests in Assam and the surrounding hills have faded even further into the mists of obscurity. This fascinating text by Ian Heath examines the peoples and places of the North-East Frontier.

Customer Reviews:

great introduction on little known subject.......2000-07-14

this book is an excellent introduction for this little known colonial theater of operations with beautifull full color illustraions i recomend this book for anyone interested in colonial campaigns and indian history

Book Description

In this intensely practical handbook, a team of leading ornithologists describe a wide range of standard methods that can be applied to the study of avian ecology and conservation. Topics covered range from surveys and tracking and handling to breeding biology, foraging behavior, and
migration. Chapters on conservation techniques describe how to assess species over-exploitation, the methods available for the intensive conservation of endangered species, and the principles involved in the maintenance and restoration of habitats. This comprehensive synthesis will be essential
reading for graduate students and researchers as well as a valuable resource for environmental consultants and professional conservationists worldwide.

Bird Ecology and Evolution is the first title in a new series of practical handbooks which include titles focusing on specific taxonomic groups as well as those describing broader themes and subjects. William J. Sutherland is the series editor.

Bird Ecology and Conservation: A Handbook of Techniques (Techniques in Ecology & Conservation)

Average customer rating:

Bird Ecology and Conservation: A Handbook of Techniques (Techniques in Ecology & Conservation)
William J.; Newton, Ian; Green, Rhys E. Sutherland
Manufacturer: Oxford University Press, USA
ProductGroup: Book
Binding: Paperback
ASIN: B000OOGQO6

Books:

Books Index

Books Home

Recommended Books